Erickson Educational Consulting, LLC
  • Home
  • Language & Literacy Resources - Requires Email Sign Up
  • About Bridget Erickson, MAESL, Language & Literacy Consultant
  • About Professional Development Programs
  • Staff Development & Training Services
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Subscribe & Register
  • Home
  • Language & Literacy Resources - Requires Email Sign Up
  • About Bridget Erickson, MAESL, Language & Literacy Consultant
  • About Professional Development Programs
  • Staff Development & Training Services
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Subscribe & Register
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

6/9/2017 4 Comments

Unraveling Difficult Sentences

Update: What does the research tell us about language & literacy?
Research Spotlight: Zipoli, R. P. (2017). Unraveling Difficult Sentences. Intervention in School and Clinic,52(4), 218-227. 

A prominent feature of literate language is the longer and more advanced syntactic structures found in decontextualized academic discourse and written text, including sentence structures that appear with relatively low frequency during casual conversation, such as verbs with a passive voice, subordinate clauses, and sentences with multiple layers of embedding (Benson, 2009; Scott, 2009; Snow & Kim, 2010). Not surprisingly, an understanding of sentence structure, or syntax, is generally recognized as making a substantial contribution to students’ comprehension of written text (Moats, 2000; RAND Reading Study Group, 2002; Scott, 2009; Snow & Kim, 2010; Spear-Swerling, 2015; Van Dijk & Kintsch, 1983)  

Unfortunately, many educators and clinicians appear to lack the syntactic knowledge and instructional skills needed to support students’ comprehension of difficult sentence structures (Justice & Ezell, 2002; Moats, 2000; Moats & Foorman, 2003; Roth, 2014; Snow, Griffin, & Burns, 2005; Steffani, 2007).
Key Findings:
  1. Four sentence structures students find difficult to comprehend:
    1.  passive verb construction
    2. adverbial clauses with temporal and causal conjunctions
    3. center-embedded relative clauses
    4. sentences with three or more clauses
  2. Comprehension problem with passive verb construction: Over reliance on the “word order” strategy and/or “probable event” strategy  The cat was chased by the dog. Students will incorrectly conclude “cat chased dog.”
​      3.  Comprehension problems with adverbial clauses with temporal and causal conjunctions:
  • Over-Reliance of “order of  mention” strategy Snape had just awarded Hufflepuff a penalty because George Weasley had hit a Bludger at him.” Students will assume that whatever is read first in the sentence is what happened first, or whatever is read first in the sentence is the cause of an action, not the effect.
  • Over-reliance on  “independent-clause-as-first-event” strategy  - After the storm hit the coast, the Red Cross arrived.  Students will conclude incorrectly that the first independent clause is the first event. 
  • Over-reliance on “probable-order-of-event” strategy  - Before you eat dinner, wash the dishes. - Students will conclude incorrectly that dishes are washed after the dinner if that fits into their background knowledge and schema.  
      4. Comprehension problems with center-embedded relative clauses occur because the greater the distance between related parts of the sentence, the more difficult it is to comprehend. Students who over rely on “word-order” strategy will have difficult processing the meaning of the sentence. These kind of clauses occur regularly in late elementary, middle and high school.
The boy who lost the dog walked home. Students will incorrectly conclude “the dog walked home.”
      5. Comprehension problems with multiple clauses or with producing sentences with multiple clauses occur in particular with students with working memory, processing speed issues and with English learners We lost the game // because our running back fumbled the ball // after he was hit. Students will only be able to identify 1 or 2 clauses and/or leave out key details of the sentence.  

Erickson’s Big Takeaways:
This is a fantastic article detailing 4 major syntactic structures that affect reading comprehension. It also provides excellent pedagogical strategies and techniques teachers can use to teach these structures to students.
 
Click here to download an adaptation of 2 of these strategies here. 
​
4 Comments
Brenna Backstrand
6/13/2017 10:17:58 am

I'm very interested in the article and the strategies, but the link didn't take me to any strategies. Can you re-post somehow? I got a membership to weebly and it still didn't show me any downloads...

Reply
Bridget Erickson
6/14/2017 07:37:25 am

Hi Brenna,

It should take you to a site that looks like a shop. In the right handside, there is a green link that says "download here." Click that and you'll get the the pdf of the strategy. Let me know if you still aren't seeing it. I can email it to you, too, but just want to make sure the site is working properly on your end.

You do have to log in to the "members only" section of the website.

Also, if for some reason the link doesn't bring you straight to the download, you can click on "resources -members only," log in, and then this download is located under "close reading" resources.

Hope that helps a bit. Thanks for looking into it!

Reply
Jessica link
10/11/2017 07:33:02 am

Hi! I tried to download an adaptation of 2 of your strategies to address unraveling difficult sentences but it says the store isn't allowing any 'purchases at the moment.' Is there another site I can download them?

Reply
Bridget Erickson
10/17/2017 08:28:50 am

Hi Jessica,
I'm sorry you're having trouble with this. Can you let me know if you still are? I will make a post right now with the resource links without needing to log in.

Thanks!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Tweets by @lang_in_schools

    Categories

    All Introductory Post Language & Culture: Loaded Labels Language & Culture Of Schooling Language & The Powerful Mainstream Research

    Archives

    October 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016

    RSS Feed


Bridget Erickson or Erickson Educational Consulting has worked with the following organizations:

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
email Bridget Erickson , President  of Erickson Educational Consulting, LLC
Erickson Educational Consulting, LLC
Subscribe now for full access to the EEC, LLC website to access free language and literacy resources.
Now scheduling PD and consulting services for districts and schools. Contact EEC, LLC